”OTT

Valentine's Day Is 2/14

Custom Jewelry Design

Are you ready to create a custom piece of jewelry that will receive compliments for generations to come?

Ring 1
Lussier_final_2

“Designing this ring with my family stones is a reminder of the generational love.”

“This ring is a constant reminder of the love that surrounds me.”

Wright_Band_Final
Ring 3

“This ring is a constant reminder of the love that surrounds me.”

Amethyst_before_during_after5
Wright_wax_try-on2

“In every glimmer of this ring, I see the reflection of our love.”

1. The Design Process

After our initial meeting, we will creatively incorporate your ideas into a Computer-Aided Design (CAD) and work together to achieve your vision.

2. Pick Your Diamonds & Gemstones

Here comes the sparkle!

Next, we will sit down together to carefully hand-select each stone that will be encased into your custom designed piece of jewelry.

We can incorporate new stones and/or use your stones. 

3. Approval

Once you approve of your design, we will bring it to life even more with a 3D wax model upon request. If tweaks are needed, we can most definitely adjust accordingly.

4. Bring Your New Custom Jewelry Home

Yay! It’s here! We will discuss proper care and cleaning. If you would like an appraisal, we would be delighted to supply you with one. We appreciate photos of the design to showcase in our design portfolios and social media.

Congrats on your new piece of custom jewelry – you can truly tell people it’s one of a kind!

5.0
5/5

(400+ Reviews)

Customer Reviews
5/5

Collette was amazing. She understood what we were looking for and created the perfect rings! I could not be happier with our design and the service of Collette and all at After Midnight Jewelers! Everyone made this a perfect experience!

The Hills
The Hills
5/5

We were absolutely thrilled with the gorgeous engagement ring we bought from After Midnight! Collette was wonderful, knowledgeable and patient and helped us find the perfect, fabulous, unique ring! We will be back before long for our wedding bands!

Diane Cullen
Diane Cullen
5/5

We worked with Ed to get my recently purchased engagement ring sized and he was very helpful and personable. He estimated that the service would take about 4 hours and it ended up only taking about 2. Very pleased with our experience!

Hayley May
5/5

The entire staff at After Midnight was so great to work with. From design to completion of our custom birthstone cross for my wife’s 40 anniversary they were there every step of the way

Robin Campbell
5/5

Highly recommend! I was looking for an experienced jeweler to redesign and reset precious stones our family has had for generations. The team is creative friendly and welcoming from the moment you walk through the doors!

Catherine Armstrong
5/5

Ed was so kind and caring for my fiancé and I to purchase our wedding bands. We felt fully taken care of and they went above and beyond to help customize my band with a unique engagement ring. I fully recommend and can’t wait to go back!

Julia Booth
5/5

Collette was great to work with – she helped me design a gorgeous custom mother’s ring for my mom. I would highly recommend After Midnight and Collette to anyone looking to create a stunning family piece!

J Combs
5/5

Scott did an amazing job making my fianceé’s dream ring come true. He took the extra time to make sure the ring would be perfect and stay perfect. Thank you Scott!!

Langley Smurthwaite
5/5

My husband and I wanted to support local, so went to AMJ for our wedding bands. Nothing fancy. Ed was very helpful, and we are very happy with the bands.

Debbie Dion
5/5

The staff at After Midnight have worked with me for more than fifteen years. We began with custom wedding bands and an engagement ring. They have been on my wife’s hand since she agreed to marry me. For many of our anniversaries I’ve counted on After Midnight to customize the perfect gift. Necklaces: include a peace sign, a hummingbird, dolphins, the Eiffel Tower, and a heartbeat diamond after a close call. Each piece, from the beginning, has included customized additions so each item has white diamonds, green diamonds and red rubies. They modified a watch to match her wedding rings. They found an amber stone with ancient life encased and fashioned a one-of-a-kind ring for me. Most recently Collette worked with me to design a fifteenth anniversary pendant for my wife. It is beautiful. Anyone can go into any jewelry store and find a nice piece of jewelry. When I walk into After Midnight we craft a unique memory together.

Mark Willett
5/5

Collette was an absolute joy to get to work with! She helped me design my engagement ring and not only did she explain everything along the way, she understood my vision and helped us fulfill it. Super thankful for the experience we had and the masterpiece we got from it!

Malia Matheson
5/5

My Fiancé and I had the pleasure of working with Collette from After Midnight Jewelers. Wow, in so many ways! Collette, helped Rob and I customize both of our wedding rings giving us both 100% what we dreamed of in our rings. The grace, patience, knowledge, kindness and her constant availability to answer our questions truly made her stand out! Thank you so much for everything. You have gained two new customers that will return again and again!

Jamie Lemire
5/5

Everyone at After Midnight Jewelers is so warm and welcoming! I had a small necklace repair done when I lived in Burlington and trusted them enough after just that to come back from our new home in Montpelier and get a wedding band for my fiancé and a custom made necklace for me from an old charm bracelet of my grandmas! Colette was so helpful, knowledgable, and available via personal text for anything at all. Another plus – I never felt pressured to buy or “sold to” at all. Just good people good at their jobs. I’ve had only great experiences there, highly recommend.

Elaine Murphy
5/5

Ed was great! We were on vacation and decided to stop in to get ourselves new wedding bands. He was very knowledgeable and didn’t try to push us towards the expensive case, only what we were looking for. 10 out of 10

Colin Files
Colin Files
5/5

Just recently switch to after midnight jewelers from another local company after hearing how excellent the service was . Well I’m so happy I did ! Amazing friendly and helpful staff, Fair pricing and honestly…. educated staff! Excellent customer service and I will definitely be recommending and coming back !

Carrie Rockwood
Carrie Rockwood
5/5

Carlee St. Amour went Above and Beyond to design our 30th Wedding Anniversary Band. We wanted Three matching Deep Blue Sapphires, so she brought in Eight for me to pick from, so I would get exactly what I wanted. The ring is fabulous! I could not have asked for anything more. Perfection.

Nancy Dabagian
5/5

Very reasonably priced, quick and just what I wanted.

Kevin McCue
5/5

Helpful, friendly and prompt. After Midnight Jewelers is my go to.

Terriann Morrison
Terriann Morrison
5/5

What a great experience! Collette was great to work with! She was super knowledgeable about the products without being too pushy. My fiancé and I left with wedding bands that we are both in love with!

Kirsten Easterson
5/5

This was my second time using AMJ, and once again was so happy with the service and my product!

Rebecca Dutkiewicz
5/5

Great personal service, friendly staff & beautiful jewelry!

Penny Marchessault
5/5

Excellent experience- courteous, caring, and professional staff!

Theresa D'Amato
5/5

Really friendly and helpful staff with wonderful selection.

Kyle Mitofsky
5/5

Great place, very helpful staff. 10/10 Will buy again!

Kenneth Noyes
5/5

I brought a pair of earrings in for repair and 2 other pairs that I wanted to have the stones reset and made into necklaces. They came out even more beautiful than I thought they would. The entire staff was friendly and helpful and their assistance and suggestions made for a great experience. I will definitely return again. Many thanks to all.

Lynee Clements
Lynne Clements
5/5

Fast service to fix my chain. Great friendly people!! Also such beautiful quality jewelry.

Amber Rhoades
Amber Rhoades
Our Location