Our HSCC Raffle event has now closed. We thank all of you for your charitable contributions.
After Midnight Jewelers logo

Custom Jewelry Design

Are you ready to create a custom piece of jewelry that will receive compliments for generations to come?

Ring 1

“Purchasing this ring was one of the best decisions I’ve made.”

“This ring is a constant reminder of the love that surrounds me.”

Ring 3

“This ring is a constant reminder of the love that surrounds me.”


“In every glimmer of this ring, I see the reflection of our love.”

1. Schedule Your Design Meeting

To schedule an in-person meeting, call us at (802) 862-3608, or click the “Text us” button below to get started.

As an After Midnight Jewelers customer, you will receive 20% OFF your wedding band with an engagement ring purchase.

2. The Design Process

After our meeting, we will incorporate your ideas into a Computer-Aided Design (CAD).

We will present up to three designs and work with you on revisions until it looks exactly like the one you’ve been dreaming of.

3. Pick Your Diamonds & Gemstones

This part of the meeting will be more hands on. You will be able to touch and select each stone that will be placed into your custom designed piece of jewelry.

You will learn more about our gemstones, including how they are ethically produced and hand selected by certified gemologists.
You will also have the ability to view lab-grown diamonds and mined diamonds side by side. Lab options can make your budget go up to 50% further. (Visit our lab diamonds page to learn more)

4. Finalize Your Design

Upon final approval of the CAD design and gemstones you’ve selected, we will receive a wax model of your piece (upon request) for you to try on.

It’s here where we will make the final adjustments prior to fabricating or casting your custom design.

5. Pick Up Your Custom Piece of Jewelry

When you pick up your new piece of jewelry, we will discuss care and cleaning as well as providing an appraisal upon request. With your permission, we will take photos of the design to showcase in our design portfolios and social media.

Congrats on your new piece of custom jewelry – you can truly tell people it’s one of a kind!


(300+ Reviews)

Customer Reviews

Scott did an amazing job making my fianceé’s dream ring come true. He took the extra time to make sure the ring would be perfect and stay perfect. Thank you Scott!!

Langley Smurthwaite

After searching for jewelers that offered custom jewelry design service, by chance I discovered After Midnight Jewelers in Vermont, and made contact with Amy. She was willing to take the time over the phone to learn about my project, and even helped me to appraise the new piece of jewelry we manufactured together. Couldn’t of been happier with the service and quality, Bravo!

Peter M

We worked with Ed to get my recently purchased engagement ring sized and he was very helpful and personable. He estimated that the service would take about 4 hours and it ended up only taking about 2. Very pleased with our experience!

Hayley May

The entire staff at After Midnight was so great to work with. From design to completion of our custom birthstone cross for my wife’s 40 anniversary they were there every step of the way

Robin Campbell

Highly recommend! I was looking for an experienced jeweler to redesign and reset precious stones our family has had for generations. The team is creative friendly and welcoming from the moment you walk through the doors!

Catherine Armstrong

Collette was great to work with – she helped me design a gorgeous custom mother’s ring for my mom. I would highly recommend After Midnight and Collette to anyone looking to create a stunning family piece!

J Combs

Ed was so kind and caring for my fiancé and I to purchase our wedding bands. We felt fully taken care of and they went above and beyond to help customize my band with a unique engagement ring. I fully recommend and can’t wait to go back!

Julia Booth

Carlee St. Amour went Above and Beyond to design our 30th Wedding Anniversary Band. We wanted Three matching Deep Blue Sapphires, so she brought in Eight for me to pick from, so I would get exactly what I wanted. The ring is fabulous! I could not have asked for anything more. Perfection.

Nancy Dabagian

My Fiancé and I had the pleasure of working with Collette from After Midnight Jewelers………. Wow, in so many ways! Collette, helped Rob and I customize both of our wedding rings giving us both 100% what we dreamed of in our rings. The grace, patience, knowledge, kindness and her constant availability to answer our questions truly made her stand out! Thank you so much for everything………you have gained two new customers that will return again and again!

Jamie Lemire

Collette was an absolute joy to get to work with! She helped me design my engagement ring and not only did she explain everything along the way, she understood my vision and helped us fulfill it. Super thankful for the experience we had and the masterpiece we got from it!

Malia Matheson
Our Location